Sam's Club vs Costco: A Comparison for Savvy Shoppers

Battle of the wholesale clubs.

Avatar photo
Written by Spencer Forman
July 2, 2024

As a deal shopper and a warehouse club junkie, people always ask me which is better: Sam's Club or Costco? It's a question that doesn't have a simple answer, as both retail giants offer compelling reasons to become a member. In this comprehensive guide, we'll dive deep into the pros and cons of each store, helping you make an informed decision about where to spend your hard-earned money. Whether you're a bulk-buying pro or considering a warehouse club membership for the first time, this comparison will give you all the information you need to choose the right store for your needs.

When it comes to warehouse club shopping, two names dominate the landscape: Sam's Club and Costco. These retail behemoths have revolutionized the way Americans shop, offering bulk quantities of groceries, household items, electronics, and more at discounted prices. Both stores operate on a membership model, providing exclusive access to their treasure troves of deals. But which one offers the better value and shopping experience? As a personal shopper who has spent countless hours in both stores, I'm here to break down the key differences and help you decide which club is right for you.

Membership Options & Costs

Let's start with the basics: getting in the door. Both Sam's Club and Costco require a membership to shop, but their tiers and pricing structures differ slightly.

Subscribe Today!

Sign up to our free deal newsletter and stay up to date on the hottest deals, secret sales and price mistakes!

By signing up, you agree to our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.

Sam's Club offers two membership levels:

  1. Club Membership ($50/year): This basic tier gives you access to all Sam's Club locations and SamsClub.com.
  2. Plus Membership ($110/year): This premium tier includes all Club benefits, plus free shipping on most items, early shopping hours, and 2% cash back on qualifying purchases (up to $500 annually).

Costco's membership options are:

  1. Gold Star Membership ($60/year): The standard membership granting access to all Costco warehouses and Costco.com.
  2. Executive Membership ($120/year): Includes all Gold Star benefits, plus 2% cash back on eligible Costco purchases (up to $1,000 annually), Includes 2 Membership Cards for you and for someone in your household, and additional benefits on select Costco services.

As you can see, Sam's Club's memberships are slightly less expensive, which could be a deciding factor for budget-conscious shoppers. However, it's important to consider the potential savings and benefits of each tier before making your decision.

Product Selection

Both Sam's Club and Costco offer an impressive array of products, from fresh produce and pantry staples to electronics and home goods. However, there are some notable differences in their selections.

Costco tends to carry more organic and premium options, particularly in their food departments. You'll find a wider variety of organic produce, meats, and packaged goods at Costco. They also tend to stock more high-end items like imported cheeses, fine wines, and gourmet snacks.

Sam's Club, on the other hand, often has a larger selection of name-brand snacks and packaged goods. If you're looking for your favorite brands in bulk, Sam's Club might have the edge here. They also tend to carry more regional and Southern brands, which can be a plus for shoppers in certain parts of the country.

When it comes to store brands, both retailers have their own lines: Kirkland Signature for Costco and Member's Mark for Sam's Club. In my experience, Kirkland Signature products are generally of slightly higher quality, often rivaling name-brand items. However, Member's Mark has made significant improvements in recent years and offers excellent value for many products.

Costco vs Sam's Club Pricing

One of the main reasons people join warehouse clubs is for the savings, so how do Sam's Club and Costco compare on price? Overall, the pricing tends to be similar between the two stores for comparable items. However, each store may have better deals on certain product categories.

In my experience, Costco often has slightly better prices and offers better deals on big-ticket items like electronics and appliances. Sam's Club, however, frequently has lower prices on packaged goods and household items.

It's worth noting that Costco is often perceived as having slightly higher quality products for comparable prices. This is particularly true for their Kirkland Signature line, which is known for its excellent quality-to-price ratio.

Costco vs Sam's Club Store Experience

The in-store experience can make or break your shopping trip, and there are some significant differences between Sam's Club and Costco in this regard.

One of Sam's Club's biggest advantages is their Scan & Go app. This feature allows you to scan items as you shop and pay directly through the app, bypassing the checkout lines entirely. It's a huge time-saver and makes the shopping experience much more convenient.

Costco, on the other hand, tends to have busier and more crowded stores, especially on weekends. While they've made efforts to streamline their checkout process, you can still expect to wait in line during peak hours.

When it comes to returns, Costco is known for its extremely generous policy. They'll accept returns on most items (with some exceptions) at any time, even without a receipt. Sam's Club also has a good return policy, but it's slightly more restrictive, with a 90-day limit on many items.

Discounted Gas Stations

Both Sam's Club and Costco offer discounted gas to their members, which can result in significant savings for frequent drivers. However, there are some differences to consider.

Costco's gas is considered higher quality, as they use Top Tier detergent gasoline at all their stations. This can lead to better engine performance and longevity. However, Costco gas stations are often extremely busy, with long lines during peak hours.

Sam's Club gas stations, while not Top Tier certified, still offer good quality fuel at competitive prices. In my experience, their gas stations tend to be less crowded, making for a quicker fill-up.

Online Shopping

In today's digital age, online shopping capabilities are increasingly important. Both Sam's Club and Costco have made strides in this area, but Sam's Club currently has the edge.

Sam's Club offers free shipping on most items for Plus members, with no minimum purchase required. They also offer curbside pickup at all locations, making it easy to grab your items without entering the store.

Costco's online selection is extensive, but their shipping fees can be high for non-members. While they do offer two-day delivery on many items, it's not free unless you meet a minimum purchase threshold.

Other Services

Both warehouse clubs offer a variety of additional services to their members, including:

  • Travel: Both offer travel booking services, but Costco Travel is generally considered to have better deals and more options.
  • Optical: Both have in-store optical centers for eye exams and glasses.
  • Pharmacy: Both offer prescription services, often at discounted rates.
  • Auto: Both offer tire installation and other basic auto services.
  • Photo: Both have photo centers for prints and photo gifts.

Costco tends to have a slight edge in the quality and variety of these additional services, particularly when it comes to travel and auto services.

So, which is better: Sam's Club or Costco?

The truth is, both offer excellent value for bulk shoppers, and the best choice for you will depend on your specific needs and preferences.

Choose Sam's Club if:

  • You want a lower membership fee
  • You prefer a less crowded shopping experience
  • You value the convenience of Scan & Go technology
  • You shop frequently online and want free shipping
  • You're looking for a wider selection of name-brand snacks and packaged goods

Choose Costco if:

  • You're interested in more organic and premium food options
  • You frequently buy big-ticket items like electronics or appliances
  • You value a more generous return policy
  • You want access to Costco Travel deals
  • You prioritize shopping at a company known for treating its employees well

Ultimately, if your budget allows and you have both stores nearby, having memberships to both Sam's Club and Costco can give you the best of both worlds. You'll have access to the widest range of products and can take advantage of the best deals at each store.

Remember, the key to making the most of your warehouse club membership is to shop smart. Stick to your list, compare prices (even within the store), and don't be swayed by bulk deals on items you won't use. With a strategic approach, either Sam's Club or Costco can help you save money and time on your shopping. I've found that both stores have their strengths, and I shop at both, depending on my needs. Whether you choose Sam's Club, Costco, or both, you're sure to find great deals and a unique shopping experience that goes beyond the traditional grocery store. Happy shopping!

Comments

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
1 Comment
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
shmuel
shmuel
17 days ago

I've been shopping at Costco for years but always wondered if I'm missing something at Sam's Club. Thanks for the comparison!

Get Deal Alerts!
Join us on Telegram and be the first to get our deals!
Get Deal Alerts
chevron-down